Lockdowns Killed Over 170,000 Americans per NBER Study in NYT
A new study from the National Bureau of Economic Research, cited in The Australian and in a New York Times op-ed today, reveals over 170,000 non-Covid excess deaths among young Americans in 2020 and 2021, most likely attributable to measures implemented to combat the coronavirus—i.e., deaths by lockdown.
The Economist puts the number even higher, at 199,000. This rate of non-Covid excess deaths among young people holds constant across European Union countries that employed strict lockdown measures, but disappears for Sweden, which did not employ such measures. According to the NBER study:
Summing our estimates across causes and age groups, we estimate 171,000 excess non-Covid deaths through the end of 2021 plus 72,000 unmeasured Covid deaths. The Economist has assembled national-level mortality data from around the world and obtains a similar U.S. estimate, which is 199,000 (including any unmeasured Covid) or about 60 persons per 100,000 population (Global Change Data Lab 2022). For the European Union as a whole, the estimate is near-identical at 64 non-Covid excess deaths per 100K. In contrast, the estimate for Sweden is -33, meaning that non-Covid causes of death were somewhat low during the pandemic. We suspect that some of the international differences are due to the standard used to designate a death as Covid, but perhaps also Sweden’s result is related to minimizing the disruption of its citizen’s normal lifestyles.
Hauntingly, the results of the NBER and Economist studies are a near-perfect match of the simple calculations of lockdown deaths performed in my book, Snake Oil.
As the New York Times notes euphemistically: “The rate of death from all causes for younger adults has risen by a bigger percentage than has the rate of death from all causes for old people.” It’s nice of the New York Times to finally print this fact, but they would appear to be, euphemistically, a day late and a dollar short—the “dollar” in this case being 200,000 young American lives.
Nice succinct summary, Michael, but I feel you're a bit too hands-off in expressing appropriate outrage. Our leaders killed these 200,000 young people as surely as if they had shot them with a gun. This is mass murder at the largest scale. And it was entirely predictable -- indeed, it was predicted by many objectors early on. I called the pandemic and lockdown policies "the Left's 9/11," and called out the massively misled thinking that resulted in lockdowns, in April of 2020. I was not alone, of course, but we really need to push for the new GOP-led Congress to hold hearings on this after the elections. Or even start now with minority-led hearings. If we don't yell to high heaven about these quantified deaths we are not going correct the record or change public health policies to avoid the inevitable repeat of these policies with the next bug that comes along, or the next or the next.
Can anyone help me program my keyboard for automatic fill-in of "bit late to the party, ain't ya fellas?" since there's gonna be a heck of a lot of this coming...